Clarke, ‘Pārājika: the Myth of Permanent and Irrevocable Expulsion’ (1999)

One of the few scholars currently focusing on vinaya literature is Shayne Clarke. His Masters’ thesis is now available online:

Clarke, Shayne. Pārājika: the Myth of Permanent and Irrevocable Expulsion from the Buddhist Order: A Survey of the Śikṣādattaka in Early Monastic Buddhism. M.A. diss., University of Canterbury, 1999. (URI & abstract / PDF.)

Dr. Clarke and myself had the pleasure of meeting at the 2007 Hamburg Conference on the Ordination of Women, where his learned presentation stood out. (Incidentally, my report of this event became controversial enough to warrant a face-to-face meeting with one of the organizers; they have since put their own views into print. Update: Readers may also wish to consult the conference papers directly. [I trust that the participants gave their consent for online publication.])

If I may say so, Clarke’s thesis reads as an unusually accomplished piece of work for an M.A. (even in its slightly expurgated online form). His understanding of the vinaya as formulated in India is based, as it ought to be, on a survey of multiple nikāyas. In subsequent publications — see this list at his official site — Dr. Clarke effortlessly bins the received view of the Pali canon as the definitive record of the lives of Indian Buddhists.

Sakai, Dharmottara / kṣaṇikatvānumāna (2010)

Sakai, Masamichi. Dharmottaras Erklärung von Dharmakīrtis kṣaṇikatvānumāna (Dharmottara / proof of monentariness [sic]). Dissertation, Universität Wien (Philologisch-Kulturwissenschaftliche Fakultät), 2010. [abstract; PDF.]

Supervised by Helmut Krasser; contains a critical edition of Pramāṇaviniścayaṭīkā II on Pramāṇaviniścaya II vv.53–55 (‘MS: 83a5–91a4’*). Continue reading “Sakai, Dharmottara / kṣaṇikatvānumāna (2010)”

Badrīratna, ‘Dharmasaṃgrahabhāṣya’ (2005)

Nareśamāna Vajrācārya (ed.) Badrīratnakṛtabhāṣyopetaḥ Nāgārjunapādaviracitaḥ Dharmasaṃgrahaḥ. Prathamo bhāgaḥ. Kathmandu: Tri-Ratna Publication, 1126 NS [2005]. 222 pp. Rs 250.

This first volume of a presumably two-volume Sanskrit commentary on Nāgārjunapāda’s Dharmasaṅgraha is by Badrīratna Vajrācārya, a self-styled leader of the Kathmandu Vajrācārya community. As far as I can tell, not much of the text is Badrī’s original contribution, the remainder having been quoted without change, correction or comment from various Indian editions of Sanskrit texts.

On p.XXII, the editor, Dr. Naresh Man Bajracharya, repeatedly describes Nāgārjuna the Mādhyamika as a “Hīnayāni” author. Astonishingly, Dr. Bajracharya at the present time is Head of Tribhuvan University’s Buddhist Studies programme, who claims that his “teaching in Nepal and abroad are well received” (cf. back cover).